"Bayou Bill" Scifres
Dedicated to the conservation and enjoyment of Indiana's natural resources
About Bayou Bill
Wild Recipes

Recent Rambles
Copyright © 2006 by Bill Scifres

Today it is a three-hour drive--roughly 150 miles on an Ontario paved road--from Thunder Bay to Armstrong, Ontario, the gateway to what must be a million lakes full of fish and a wilderness for those who want to get away from it all. 

It took a whole day--daylight to dusk--some 40 years ago when Dan Gapen, one of Hoosier outdoorsdom’s favorite adopted sons--drove his pickup camper up the mud/gravel clearing that was more trail than road. 

Behind us all the way was Dan’s 14-foot runabout, topped with a 15-foot aluminum canoe, fishing and camping paraphernalia, enough food, we thought, to keep a young army from starvation’s door, and a force that drove us to search for streams that hosted native brook trout. 

You see, Dan, a Minnesota fishing tackle manufacturer, had “played” the Indianapolis Boat, Sport & Travel Show the year before as the expert that he was/is, and I (as outdoor editor of the Indianapolis Star) had spent a lot of time pumping information on brook trout from the man who had  guided brookie anglers on Ontario’s famous Lake Nipigon and stream  environs. 

“Tell you what,” Dan said one-day as we talked at the Coliseum tank where he displayed his fly-fishing prowess, “Let’s go looking for brookies next summer in the area north of Armstrong.” 

It was like waving a red flag at a bull. On a Sunday of the following July I flew to Minneapolis, and early the next morning we headed for the Canadian border. It was too late to tackle the road to Armstrong when we arrived at Thunder Bay, on the north shore of Lake Superior, but we were up and at it early the next morning. Likewise, when we arrived at Armstrong, it was too late to head north on Caribou Lake, but after a hearty breakfast we loaded our gear in the canoe which we trailed behind the runabout with a special rope rig that Dan had mastered as a kid while moving anglers and canoes around on Lake Nipigon. 

The secret, Dan explained, is having the towrope tied to forward thwarts on both sides of the canoe, and joined in such a manner under the bow of the canoe to keep the bow up out of the water at high speed. Rigged in this manner, the forward third of the canoe barely touches the water. Heavy items ride in the back of the canoe. But even with this rig, Dan says it is wise to run slowly when crossing the wake of other boats. 

At the north end of Caribou Lake, where this waterway takes on river status, we pulled the runabout high and dry (hidden in the buck brush) and stashed the outboard motor some distance from the boat. Then we were off down this north-flowing river to Smoothrock Lake, which, at that time, supported only one fishing camp. 

When we were well into the swift water of the river, Dan guided the canoe to a large flat rock at the middle of the 200-yard-wide strip of rushing blue-black water. 

 “Let’s fix some lunch,”Dan said, pulling a skillet and sauce pans from a pack, and tying a small, black jig-worm combination onto the line of a spinning outfit. Then, with some driftwood collected from the rock, he started a fire and announced we would have walleye filets, fried potatoes, and corn for lunch. 

This, of course, required catching the walleyes, but two casts was all he needed to solve that problem. Once the potato skillet was sizzling, two walleyes were cleaned and they soon were sizzling in a skillet. Half an hour later we were having lunch. As we dined and talked, Dan noted that we had never competed while fishing, but we would do so soon as the dishes were cleaned up and the canoe was repacked to continue our journey to Smoothrock Lake. 

“You like spinner-bucktail lures,” Dan said, “I have a new lure that I want to show you . . . it’s better than anything you ever fished with.” With that, he picked up the spinning outfit with which he had caught the two walleyes we had consumed and shook the lure in my  face. 

“I call it The Hairy Worm,” Dan said, pointing out that he had been experimenting with it for some time, and soon would put it on the market with other lures he produced and sold. 

“I want you to fish your spinner-bucktail lures (they were not yet known as spinner baits),” he said and I will outfish you with The Hairy Worm. We stood side by side casting into the swift, blue water. 

As Dan’s lure settle toward the bottom he set the hook and horsed out a nice walleye that he promptly released. His next cast was an instant replay of the first, but this time he was much more vocal: 

“Hairy Worm strikes again,” Dan yelled, noting that the city boy and his spinner-bucktail couldn’t get a bite. 

Dan made five casts and caught (and released) as many walleyes, his vocal tirade growing with each fish. On the sixth cast he was having so much fun deriding me and my lures that he lost the fish before he could flip it up on the rock. That cooled Dan a bit, but he made two more casts and caught two more walleyes for an overall performance of e seven fish on eight casts, plus the loss of the other fish with his tomfoolery. It all happened as I fished my best, but couldn’t get a bite. 

To say that I was impressed is not a bad way to put it.  But I was also stubborn and finally tied on a lure known as the Lutz Boomerang as we fished the big waters of Smoothrock Lake. This lure, designed and produced by a Texan, brought good success for me and I was able to compete (though I could not beat) Dan and his jig-worm combo. 

Finally, though, I hung the Lutz Boomerang in very deep water as I fished just before dark one day from a big rock outcropping where we were camped. Dan dropped his dishwashing chores and went through the motions of helping me retrieve my lure, but could not contain a vociferous outburst of joy (and I think he was doing a little dance) when my line snapped and the star of my lure stable was forever gone. 

Like the nomadic anglers that we were, by day Dan and I searched the bays of Smoothrock Lake for tributaries that might host native brook trout. But while we did not find the little red-bellies of our dreams, we did find great fishing for walleye, and occasionally whitefish would offer their surface-feeding bonanza at dusk for fly rod action. 

Dan maintained that landing a whitefish with a fly rod from a canoe without a net was requisite to being a fisherman. He qualified; I didn’t. 

One night when the bacon, eggs and most of the other foods had smelled up their last campsite, and we had been on a steady diet of fried walleye filets, fried potatoes, and canned beans for several days, Dan  said he didn’t think he could stomach another walleye filet. 

I told him I would fix the fish that night and he would like it. 

With skin and scales on the connected filets of two walleyes, I wired them to a large, flat rock with wire fishing line (skin side against the rock), smeared the white meat with butter and sprinkled it with salt  and pepper. I propped the rock up close to a beautiful bed of coals, an when the potatoes and beans were ready we dined on what Dan said was “the best walleye he had ever eaten.” The editor of Outdoor Life Magazine must have like my culinary concept, too. A year later the cover of that magazine featured a campfire scene with fish being broiled on a flat rock tilted to utilize the heat of a campfire. And a month later the magazine featured my Smoothrock Lake story. 

I could say that this is more or less the end of the Dan Gapen/Hairy Worm story. When we returned to Armstrong, and motored back to Thunder Bay over a road that seemed to have gotten worse in ten days, Dan gave me the small handful of Hairy Worms that he had left . . .  the idea being that I would try them on the denizens that called Hoosier waters home. 

Try them, I did. And I found the lure equally as good in Hoosierland as it had been in the wilderness.  Largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, rock bass (goggle-eye), and many sunfish species--including the feisty little red-bellies (long-eared sunfish), punkinseeds, minnows of numerous species . . . they all hit the Hairy Worm like it was going out of style. 

The Hairy Worm quickly became the star of Dan’s stable of artificial lures. They sold like hotcakes in Indiana, and I presume, everywhere else. 

End of story? Not by a fisherman’s dilapidated hat! 

Dan found combining soft plastic with flat jig heads, and rubber bands (for legs) so successful that in less than a year he had the Hairy Worm’s mate--the Ugly Bug--on the market and that spring he brought the tandem to Indiana’s newly-opened Monroe Reservoir (must have been 1968) to give a gathering of Hoosier anglers a hands-on introduction. 

But, at this juncture, Dan wanted to enhance these lures (and the sales thereof) by adding an “L-shaped spinner. 

Dan distributed both lures (with and without spinners) to those of us who would be fishing (there were three or four boats), noting that he would appreciate it if we would give some thought to a name for the lures when rigged with spinners. 

Shortly after noon we were fishing Boy Scout Bay with great success for crappies, bass and a smattering of other species. Anglers in all of the boats were enjoying fast action, but there was a fly in the soup. Rolling in from the southwest were thunderheads that spelled trouble, so we beached the boats, pulled the lunch coolers out and scrambled to the Boy Scout campground that was so new, totally unused, that the pit toilets became our shelters. 

It was a violent storm, complete with crashing thunder and jagged lightning bolts that chilled my spine as I stood on a toilet seat and watched in awe through the four-inch opening between roof and sides of our shelter. 

All day I had been racking my brain for a name for Dan’s lures. It came o me like a shot out of the blue: 

“I got it, Dan! . . .  I got it!” I yelled at the top of my voice to be heard over a clap of thunder. 

“You got what?“ Dan asked.. 

“The name for your lures,” I said . . . “Hairy Worm Plus, and Ugly Bug Plus.“ So it would be. 

End of story? Not quite, but maybe time for an intermission. 

You see, Dan is coming back to Indianapolis Boat, Sport & Travel Show this year after a 15-year hiatus. He will be in a double Tackletown exhibit (Booths 421-422). 

Although Dan has not marketed the Hairy Worm for a few years, the Ugly Bug (with or without spinners) still is a fast-selling pony in his stable. And though I find it difficult to admit, the latter seems to out-produce the former. 

Still, Dan has told me that, for old time’s sake, he is going to try to put together some Hairy Worms for anglers of the state that made the lure so popular. 

Dan’s a busy man . . . running a hook shop is not an easy chore . . . so I can’t guarantee the Hairy Worms. I can guarantee the Ugly Bug, not to mention an interesting interlude if you stop to chat with the best angler I have ever known.

Click on thumbnail image for enlarged view.

thelures.jpg (13496 bytes)
gapen1.jpg (23936 bytes)
Dan Gapen’s Hairy Worm (left) with and without spinner, and their counterparts, The Ugly Bug, right. Dan liked my method of preparing walleye filets so much that he tried his own version the next day

Go to home page.


All columns, stories, and photos are copyrighted by Bill Scifres and may not be reproduced in any form without prior permission from the author's family.  For reproduction permission and media usage fees, contact: Scifres Family, 6420 East 116th Street, Fishers, IN 46038, E-mail: billscifres@aol.com

Return to beginning of document
Return to Bayou Bill's Home Page